Portrait, legend, and strike.
Read the obverse portrait and the legend around it, then the reverse type — together they usually identify ruler, mint, and date range. Size and metal narrow the denomination before you read a single letter.
Hammered coins are slightly irregular with off-centre strikes; milled (machine-struck) coins are round and even, a later technology. A coin that is perfectly round yet claims to be medieval has some explaining to do.
Piercings, clipped edges, mount marks, and graffiti are part of the coin’s biography — record them as history, not just damage. Weigh the coin and measure its diameter; both are diagnostic.
Wear should be consistent across the design; artificially “aged” fakes often show even, featureless surfaces or casting bubbles. Transcribe the legend letter by letter, gaps and all — an honest partial reading beats a guessed attribution.
Identifying tokens and jettons
Identifying Roman silver coins